Scotty Cameron Super Select 23 Del Mar Putter

Scotty Cameron Super Select 23 Del Mar Putter Review

Introduction

The Scotty Cameron Super Select 23 Del Mar Putter (priced at $449) is a premium
putter from Titleist’s Scotty Cameron line—one of the most recognizable names in high-end golf
equipment. This putter sits in the midsize mallet / heel-toe weighted blade category and is
designed for golfers who want refined feel, consistent roll, and confidence on the greens. The Del Mar shape is
traditionally favored by players who prefer a slight-arc putting stroke, though it can also work
for golfers who like a compact mallet look without moving to a full-size mallet.

Product Overview

The Super Select 23 Del Mar aims to deliver a tour-inspired blend of precision milling,
responsive feel, and stable head behavior through impact. It’s positioned as a
luxury option for serious golfers who put a premium on sound/feel feedback and craftsmanship, and who are willing
to pay for brand pedigree and refined finishing.

Appearance, Materials, and Aesthetic

Visually, the Del Mar stands out with its compact, rounded mallet profile—more substantial than a traditional
blade, yet still sleek and streamlined. The head shape tends to frame the ball well and can inspire confidence for
players who like a slightly larger footprint behind the ball without the “bulk” of a modern high-MOI mallet.

Scotty Cameron putters are known for their meticulous machining and finishing, and the Super Select line typically
reflects that with:

• Clean toplines and crisp edges that provide a premium “milled” look at address.
• High-end surface finishing that’s designed to look tour-ready and resist glare reasonably well
  in normal sunlight.
• A classic, understated aesthetic that prioritizes traditional shape language over flashy, busy
  alignment graphics.

Unique to the Del Mar style is the way the rounded, compact mallet geometry can make alignment feel more “natural”
for players who struggle with squarer blade shapes. It also tends to look balanced sitting behind the ball—neither
too open nor too closed—when properly fit.

Key Features & Specifications

Exact specs can vary by build (length, lie, loft, grip), but the Super Select Del Mar generally targets the
following performance characteristics:

• Premium Scotty Cameron milling: A precision-milled face and head aimed at consistent roll and
  predictable feedback.
• Compact mallet / heel-toe weighting: Designed to provide more stability than a narrow blade
  while preserving a traditional look.
• Player-focused stroke compatibility: Often best suited to golfers with a
  slight-to-moderate arc stroke path.
• Alignment-friendly shape: The Del Mar profile can help some golfers set the face square more
  easily, especially if they prefer rounded geometry.
• Tour-inspired fit and finish: Premium cosmetics and attention to detail consistent with the
  brand’s reputation.
• Price point: $449, placing it firmly in the top tier of retail putters.

Note: For the most accurate configuration details (head weight, toe hang, loft/lie, grip type), it’s best to
confirm the exact build specs from the retailer or Titleist/Scotty Cameron product listing, as options can vary.

Performance and On-Green Experience

1) Short Putts (Inside 6 Feet)

On short putts, the Del Mar’s compact mallet shape can provide a reassuring presence behind the ball. Stability on
slightly imperfect strikes is typically better than a very narrow blade, which helps when you don’t catch the
center perfectly under pressure. The feel tends to be crisp and informative: center strikes feel
solid, while slight mishits are noticeable enough to encourage better consistency without feeling harsh.

If you’re a golfer who tends to “steer” short putts, this putter’s balanced, premium feedback can help you commit
to a firm, simple stroke—though it won’t mask poor face control the way some extremely high-MOI mallets can.

2) Mid-Range Putts (6–20 Feet)

In the mid-range, distance control is largely about repeatable contact and predictable roll. The Super Select
Del Mar’s milling and head design typically reward a smooth tempo. The putter feels responsive enough to let you
“sense” the strike, which many better players prefer when dialing in pace on different green speeds.

Golfers who like a little more face rotation may find the Del Mar comfortable, especially compared to face-balanced
mallets that can feel resistant to an arcing stroke. If your stroke is very straight back/straight through, you
might prefer a different configuration with less toe flow.

3) Long Putts and Lag Putting (20+ Feet)

For lag putting, the biggest test is whether the head feels stable while still offering touch. The Del Mar’s
slightly larger head profile can help keep the face from wobbling during a longer stroke, and the feedback can aid
in calibrating speed.

That said, golfers who struggle with consistent contact on long putts may still benefit more from a larger,
perimeter-weighted mallet designed specifically for maximum forgiveness. The Del Mar is a “players” shape—it offers
stability, but it’s not the most forgiving style in the market.

4) Different Green Conditions

• Fast greens: The responsive feel helps with delicate taps, but it demands good tempo control.
  Players who get “handsy” may find it reveals mistakes quickly.
• Slow greens: You can be more assertive with the stroke; the head’s stability can help keep the
  face square when you need to add a bit more hit.
• Bumpy / inconsistent greens: No putter eliminates bumps, but consistent roll characteristics and
  solid feel can help you stay confident. Still, alignment and start line matter more than ever in these
  conditions.

Pros and Cons

Pros

• Premium craftsmanship and finish consistent with Scotty Cameron’s high-end reputation.
• Confidence-inspiring compact mallet shape that bridges the gap between blades and large mallets.
• Excellent feedback that helps skilled golfers refine strike quality and distance control.
• Great fit for slight-arc strokes, where a bit of natural toe flow can feel more intuitive.
• Strong resale/collector interest in the Scotty Cameron ecosystem (varies by condition and market).

Cons

• High price ($449), which may be difficult to justify compared with many excellent mid-priced putters.
• Not the most forgiving head style versus large, high-MOI mallets—especially on off-center hits.
• Stroke-fit sensitivity: Golfers with a very straight putting path may prefer a more face-balanced model.
• Performance gains can be incremental if you’re already using a well-fit putter; improvement depends heavily on fit and stroke.

Conclusion

The Scotty Cameron Super Select 23 Del Mar Putter is a polished, premium option for golfers who
value feel, craftsmanship, and a classic-yet-compact mallet profile. It’s particularly appealing
if you have a slight-arc stroke and want a putter that offers stability without losing the
responsiveness and traditional character that many players seek.

Its biggest drawback is the obvious one: cost. At $449, it’s an investment, and the real value
comes when the putter’s shape, toe flow, and setup match your stroke. If you can get fit for length/lie/loft and
confirm the Del Mar’s balance suits your motion, this putter can be a long-term gamer that delivers consistent,
confidence-building performance on the greens.